The sauce is only half of a butter chicken. The blend stirred in at the end is garam masala, and the jarred kind was ground months before it reaches your kitchen. Toasting whole spices and grinding them yourself takes about fifteen minutes, and the result is warmer and stronger than a jar that has been open since spring.
It is a small batch on purpose. Whole spices keep their flavour for a long time, but once they are ground the clock starts, so this makes about a third of a cup, enough to use while it is still at its best.
Making the blend
- Toast. Put the coriander, cumin, cardamom, peppercorns, cloves, cinnamon, star anise, and fennel (if you are using it) in a dry skillet over medium heat. Toast 3 to 4 minutes, shaking the pan often, until fragrant and a shade darker. Your nose is the timer here: strong and fragrant means done, and two extra minutes takes them from toasted to burnt and bitter.
- Cool. Tip the spices onto a plate and let them cool completely. Warm spices release their oils in the grinder and clump instead of milling into a powder.
- Grind and jar. Grind everything to a fine powder in a spice grinder or a clean coffee grinder, running it a little longer than you think you need, since coarse bits taste gritty in a smooth sauce. Stir in the nutmeg, transfer to an airtight jar, and label it.
Batch sizes
- Base mix: about 1/3 cup (about 5 tablespoons)
- 2x batch: about 2/3 cup
- Serving: 1 teaspoon, and the batch makes about 16 teaspoons. The nutrition on the card is per teaspoon, estimated from the ingredient totals.
- Gift jar: the full base mix fits a small 4 ounce jar. Card: “Stir 1 tablespoon into butter chicken sauce at the end of cooking.”
Using the blend
Butter chicken: stir in 1 tablespoon at the end of cooking, right before the cream goes in.
Curries: bloom a teaspoon in butter before the onions. It perfumes the whole pot before anything else lands in it.
Beyond curry: roasted vegetables, lentil soup, rice with a knob of butter, savoury marinades, and roast chicken all take it well.
On this site it shows up in the butter chicken rice, the Instant Pot tomato coconut masala chicken, and the curry air fryer chickpeas.
Variations and swaps
- Sweet note: add the optional fennel seeds. The gentle anise flavour suits meat dishes.
- Extra warm: add 1/2 teaspoon of black cumin or a second star anise.
- Milder: halve the black peppercorns for warmth without the pepper bite.
- No spice grinder: a clean coffee grinder works. If it still smells like coffee, grind a spoonful of rice through it first and discard the rice.
Common questions
My blend tastes bitter. The spices went too far in the skillet. Toast gently, shake the pan often, and pull them as soon as they smell fragrant. Can I use ground spices instead? In a pinch, yes. Use about three quarters of the listed amounts, since ground spices measure denser than whole, warm them briefly in a dry skillet until fragrant, and skip the grinding. It will not be as vivid. Should I crack the cardamom pods first? You do not have to; the husks grind down in a decent spice grinder. For the smoothest powder, crack the pods and grind just the seeds. Is it gluten free? The spices themselves are. Check the label on any spice you buy if that matters to you.
Two more places the blend earns its keep: the KFI butter chicken, where jarred sauces do the heavy lifting and the spice wakes them up, and the masala sizzled garlic green beans, where it sizzles in hot oil with garlic until the beans blister.